New Bazin translation

Does anyone know anything about this?  Caboose is launching a new translation, by Timothy Barnard, of Bazin’s What is Cinema? at SCMS Tokyo in May, and they are making some grandiose claims:

Rarely does a new translation radically alter our understanding of a thinker’s work. This is that book.

The translator’s meticulous research into Bazin’s sources has led him to a connection between the ideas of Bazin and Bertolt Brecht and to a pseudonymous article believed to have been written by Siegfried Kracauer.

from the email announcing this:

Avoiding the untold mistakes found in previous English translations, which have truly deformed Bazin’s ideas and skewed our understanding of them, Barnard renders Bazin’s writing, which sought to make his subtle theories accessible to general readers in his own day, even more accessible to today’s student.

I’m not necessarily saying I’m skeptical. Just wondering if anyone knows anything about this.

  • http://bombproofcinema.blogspot.com/ Chris aka Sindri

    Hi Erik,

    I offer this review that might be of interest in regards to the Bazin translation: http://www.offscreen.com/biblio/pages/essays/bazin_revisited/
    from Offscreen.

    I agree that these are bold statements to make on the part of the publisher (of course they’re going to hawk the book) but reading Tonato’s short piece, it might be worthwhile to see the new translation.

  • erik

    Thanks for the link. I will definitely check out the new translation, as Bazin figures pretty prominently in my work.

  • Panta Gruel

    There are PDF-format excerpts from the translation on the publisher’s website. Why not check them out and see what you think?

  • erik

    I have looked at some other sites about this, and it seems very promising. The excerpts I have seen look concise and well translated. Very exciting. There is also a good discussion of this new translation here: http://www.girishshambu.com/blog/2009/03/andre-bazin-caboose.html